Hero image

Mr Pizza

+1 208-357-5560
164 S State St, Shelley, ID 83274 United States of America
Open Today: Closed

Amenities

Service options
  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
Popular for
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
Offerings
  • Comfort food
  • Quick bite
Amenities
  • Good for kids
  • High chairs
Atmosphere
  • Casual
  • Cozy
Crowd
  • College students
  • Groups
  • Tourists

Best PlaceJuice Reviews

If I could give this place a -10 I would. Dirty, the pizza was like cardboard with no flavor, the ranch looked like and tasted like milk with nothing else in it. The service was horrible. When their ice machine was not working, I asked if it was out and the kid goes “I don’t know probably” and walked off. They gave you small white styrofoam cups for soda and you had to use tinfoil squares to take your leftovers in. Nothing at all like the Mr. pizza in Blackfoot.
A total dive but that’s it’s charm! Growing up the $2 lunch special was one of my faves. Living in Boise now, I still crave it❤️
The pizza is incredible. Best pizza in East Idaho.
Wish they were clean with no flies so I could take my wife but I’ll pick it up a couple times per month.
This place amazes me. The owners are amazing people. The pizza and bread sticks are wonderful the lunch special is fantastic. I drive from idaho falls to eat here.
Disgustingly dirty, ranch looked like milk and couldn't even eat the salad as they served brown lettuce. I wiped the table off with a paper towel and it was completely brown. Ordered largest pizza and it was 3 inches in from the outside of the pan.
F your looking for decor and "ambiance" move on. Hands down the best economically priced pizza out there. The crust is light. Its not too thick. Not too thin. It taste very very nice. If your looking for pizza Chicago deep dish quality, again, this isnt it. The best thing its got going for it is the taste to price ratio. Its weighted so heavily in favor of the "taste" category. If you want a really really good pizza for an incredibly fair price..this is the pinnacle. Id eat this any day over dominos or pizza hut. And its less expensive. If your flat broke, for $2 you can get full at lunchtime. What more should be said.
The best pizza I've ever had! I've always loved Mr Pizza, but they have really stepped their game up lately. Breadsticks are the best!
I used to work in shelley, I didn't have a whole lot of money for lunches thankfully I discovered Mr. Pizza! From the first time I went in there the staff was always super nice. I love their food. The options are great and they are willing to add to the pizza even if it's already done. I personally loved the marinara sauce. I'm so happy for this business, we need more business with this mentality. Keep up the great work Mr. Pizza ????

Quick Facts About Mr Pizza

Mr Pizza place has received a mix of positive and negative comments. In order to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the restaurant, let's analyze each aspect mentioned in the comments.
1. Cleanliness and Appearance: Several comments highlight the negative aspect of the restaurant's cleanliness. Terms like "dirty," "disgustingly dirty," and "brown lettuce" indicate that the cleanliness standards are not satisfactory. This is a significant weakness of Mr Pizza place, as cleanliness is crucial for any food establishment.
2. Pizza Quality: On the positive side, many comments mention the incredible taste and quality of the pizza. Terms like "incredible," "best pizza," "wonderful," and "best pizza I've ever had" show that the taste and quality of the pizza are highly regarded by customers. This is a significant strength for Mr Pizza place, as having a delicious product is crucial for a pizzeria.
3. Service: The comments regarding the service at Mr Pizza place are mixed. While one comment mentions the horrible service, another comment praises the staff for being super nice. The inconsistency in service quality suggests that there might be some issues with the training or management of the staff. In terms of strengths and weaknesses, it is clear that there is room for improvement in the service aspect.
4. Price and Value: Customers mention the economic price of the pizza as a strength. Phrases like "best economically priced pizza," "incredibly fair price," and "less expensive" highlight the value proposition of Mr Pizza place. This is a significant strength, as customers appreciate good quality food at affordable prices.
5. Menu Options: One customer specifically mentions the wide variety of options available at Mr Pizza place, including the flexibility to customize the pizza. This variety and flexibility cater to different preferences, making it a strength for the restaurant.
6. Ambiance: One comment suggests that the restaurant may lack decor and ambiance. While this may not be a significant factor for some customers who solely focus on the quality of the food, it can be a weakness for those looking for a pleasant dining experience.
Based on the comments, below is a summary of the strengths and weaknesses of Mr Pizza place:
Strengths: 1. Delicious and high-quality pizza. 2. Economic pricing and good value for money. 3. Wide variety of menu options. 4. Friendly staff. 5. Flexibility to customize orders.
Weaknesses: 1. Cleanliness issues. 2. Inconsistent service quality. 3. Lack of decor and ambiance.
In conclusion, Mr Pizza place has both strengths and weaknesses. While the pizza quality and affordability are praised by customers, cleanliness issues and inconsistent service are drawbacks. Addressing these weaknesses and maintaining the strengths can help Mr Pizza place improve and attract more customers.


Place Pictures

Resim
Küçük Resim 1 Küçük Resim 1 Küçük Resim 1 Küçük Resim 1 Küçük Resim 1 Küçük Resim 1 Küçük Resim 1 Küçük Resim 1

Today

Opening Hours

Monday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Tuesday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Wednesday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Thursday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Friday 07:00 AM - 08:00 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed

How to go there

Location